light? dark?

I can’t seem to make up my mind (I blame lack of sleep, but thats my own fault. Staying up late knittin.) So please help me decide. I’m knitting a cardigan for a new(ish) cousin, and I can’t decide on the toggle color

I can't decide! which toggles?

click here for the really big size

the top (lighter) one? or the bottom (darker) one?

I like the darker one. (I rubbed some paint onto the toggle. If I do this I’m going to paint it with a coat of poly so the paint doesn’t come off in the wash)

Pleeeease tell me what you think. As, I can’t seem to make up my mind!